The I Index

Amanda Dennis,
Times Literary Supplement (UK)
... articulating tenderness and regret alongside shame and rage.
Jacquelyn Marie Gallo,
Brooklyn Rail
He uses his personal experience to demonstrate the ways women suffer from subordination and masculine domination; and political attacks on his family to show the ways legislation can further denigrate the poor. In essence, Louis’s intimate narrative creates a pathway to understanding the complex, symbiotic nature between systems of power.
Anthony Cummins,
The Guardian (UK)
The material remains painful, yet Louis’s mellowing tone can be seen in how much more gently he portrays the grim details of Monique’s occupation than he did in The End of Eddy, a luridly styled book undeniably out to shock. The heartbreaking details tend to be quieter, often related to a kind of survivor’s guilt as Louis looks back to his mother’s ill-starred attempts to conjure an escape during his childhood.
Wyatt Mason,
The New York Times Book Review
... translated into English with unobtrusive flair.
Eric Newman,
The Los Angeles Review of Books
The portrait we get of Monique’s life is constructed out of vignettes gleaned from scrapbooks and interviews, rendered in the signature collage style that Louis deftly uses to connect his mother’s experience to a broader narrative of working-class struggle.
Rhoda Feng,
The Harvard Review
Crisply translated.
JENNIFER KABAT,
Frieze
... unflinching.
David Keymer,
Library Journal
The writing is intensely lyrical but the subject rubs up against the political.
Annie Bostrom,
Booklist
... ravishing.
CHARLES ARROWSMITH,
The Los Angeles Times
The reasons he has charmed readers are obvious. Louis writes simply and clearly. He’s disarmingly frank and earnest in a way that makes it difficult to stop looking — like a child who won’t break eye contact.
Hannah Weber,
Words Without Borders
Even though Louis’s prose is assuredly polished, it often feels as if he is deliberately exposing his process—his arguments are not always consistent, but it is through the relentless investigative writing that he develops insight and nuance, and revises his ideas. Louis’s style is detached, slippery, decidedly unsentimental, but nonetheless moving. He repeats phrases word for word, like a leitmotif, sometimes giving them a whole page spread to themselves. The use of white space and blank pages is telling; in music, the rests are just as important as the notes.
Anne-Sylvaine Chassany,
The Financial Times (UK)
The book is short on purpose, Louis explained recently, to increase its impact and make it 'inescapable'. And indeed it does not take long to finish, but perhaps at the expense of substance. One would want to know more about his mother, Monique Bellegueule, but even Louis concedes that he does not have much to work with.
MARCUS HIJKOOP,
Jacobin
Louis returns to much of the same subject matter as in his debut but adopts a more sociological approach, taking the liberty to draw conclusions on behalf of the reader. The reader’s reception of these books will depend largely on whether they find Louis’s diagnoses persuasive, and whether they trust him more as a social critic or as a novelist.
Houman Barekat,
The Spectator (UK)
The key to Louis’s literary appeal is that he engages with complex themes while keeping things relatively simple. His elegant concision – his books are less than 200 pages long – ensures that candour never lapses into self-indulgence. On the down side, he is prone to certain faddish turns of phrase, such as the lazy (and slightly pretentious) characterisation of oppressive social mores as ‘violence’, and using ‘bodies’ as a synonym for ‘people’...That said, his wry description of his younger brother’s gaming addiction as ‘a radically contemporary kind of life’ is pleasingly withering.
Simon Leser,
Bookforum
Of the more dramatic developments brought about by Louis’s constant unearthing of new layers to his life, or to the narrative of that life—no longer as forthright as it once was—has been his retreat from the straightforwardly political. Despite the renewed assertion, in A Woman, that his writing is a 'political manifesto,' where each sentence is sharpened like 'the blade of a knife,' we are far from the direct accusations of Who Killed My Father...One is hard-pressed to find a consistent critique behind it; if this was a manifesto, you would be forgiven for wondering whether it called for the government’s overthrow or a Great National Debate.
Steve Donoghue,
Open Letters Review
... preserves both the original’s leaden, portentous title and, as an added bonus for the $20 asking price, every other word in this limp and boring bit of memoir is likewise leaden and portentous. And once again, the fault cannot be laid at the feet of the translator; Tash Aw has done everything human ingenuity can do to flush some life into these dead-lily pages. No, it’s the author’s original French that rolls half-upright on its afternoon couch, looks around, and blandly waits to be applauded for at least seeming to be semi-conscious.

Kirkus
... slim, tender.

Publishers Weekly
In this penetrating work, French novelist Louis turns a sharp yet forgiving gaze on the struggles of his mother, and the complicated bond he shared with her.