The I Index

Cassandra Luca,
The Harvard Crimson
To be clear, none of these subjects are new, and men who read this book might not learn anything revolutionary. What Orenstein does excellently, however, is condense, clarify, and draw out the perspectives of the boys and men that she interviewed — their voices, interspersed with her own, lift the book up, hopefully showing readers that they are not alone in their experiences.
Lauren Smith Brody,
The New York Times Book Review
Orenstein’s Boys & Sex is a natural follow-up to her 2016 best seller Girls & Sex. The young men we meet here tend to be hyperarticulate — to the extent that I was initially skeptical of their eloquence.
Rachel A.G Gilman,
The Columbia Journal
Through a combination of extensive interviews with young men and sociological research, the book seeks to move beyond the space of think pieces written by men and actually include them in the conversation. It gives readers a digestible overview of the problem.
Steve Donoghue,
Open Letters Review
...an equally-indispensable companion volume...which duplicates the methodology of the previous book: dozens of interviews, a great deal of supporting research, and most of all the author’s consistently superb analyses.

Publishers Weekly
... [a] candid and fascinating portrait of young American masculinity ...Orenstein’s scope is wide, as she delves into the lives of gay and transgender boys and men and interviews young black men at predominantly white schools who stringently follow the rules of 'consent,' wary of severe punishment for any hint of improper behavior.

Kirkus
Candid information on what boys really think and do when it comes to sex.