Skip to main content

The I Index

Martin Bentham,
The Evening Standard (UK)
... stimulating.
Allan Massie,
The Scotsman (UK)
Much is thought-provoking, much fascinating, much in this accumulation of detail wearisome, much confusing. I would guess that this is a book many will dip into and find fascinating information and speculation, but few will read through.
Damon Linker,
The New York Time Book Review
... a book that hopscotches breezily across continents and centuries while also displaying an impressive command of the latest research in a large number of specialized fields, among them medical history, epidemiology, probability theory, cliodynamics and network theory.
Matthew Syed,
The Sunday Times (UK)
Throughout you glimpse Ferguson’s subtlety, eloquence and breadth of scholarship. But the book has a big defect — and not just because instant history is always fraught with danger. No, the problem is that it covers so much ground at such a breathless pace that the moment you hope that you are going to get Ferguson’s reasoned take on an issue, he has already moved on.
Rafael Behr,
The Guardian (UK)
It is not a gloomy book, although it dwells often on our collective failure to learn from past mistakes. Ferguson’s interest is the patterns and systems that emerge from the repetition, to which end he skips quite breezily through a rich catalogue of gruesome, miserable experiences.
Chris Barsanti,
PopMatters
Readers...will find two Ferguson on display. Besides the conservative columnist...the serious, if sometimes wrong-headed historian, is also in attendance.
Andrew Anthony,
The Observer (UK)
... like someone who doesn’t want to let a moment’s research go unused, he crams the book with a dizzying array of theories, characters and references that, while sometimes informative and occasionally amusing, combine to a deadening effect.
Douglas Alexander,
Financial Times (UK)
Although the writing is compelling, the sheer range of examples makes it difficult always to hold on to a sense of the overall thesis; each tree is beautifully drawn but this reader at least sometimes struggled to retain a sense of the wood. Forecasting, network science, economics, epidemiology, together with the psychology of leadership are all considered in a dazzlingly broad examination of the 'politics of catastrophe'. Reassuringly, Ferguson concludes that human behaviour does actually matter in determining the impact of disasters, whatever their origins or character. The vulnerability of the system, rather than the weakness of the leadership, is fundamental to Ferguson’s account of how catastrophes unfold.
Mark Whitaker,
The Washington Post
... reads like an extended version of one of those high-price talks.
David Aaronovitch,
The Times (UK)
... often feels like a special disasters season of University Challenge, in which all the answers are given by an N Ferguson of Stanford University. There are different themes to his chapters, but after a while they all blur..
Ian Beacock,
The New Republic
Ferguson’s fifteenth and latest book, Doom: The Politics of Catastrophe, is meant to set the record straight on the pandemic, rebut the most 'idiotic' arguments made about Covid-19, and situate our year of disastrous living in longer historical perspective.
Laura Hiatt,
Library Journal
Like [Ferguson's] other works, Doom is well-researched, well-argued, and all-encompassing. Ferguson uses the depth and breadth of his knowledge to cogently argue for a new understanding of catastrophic events.

Kirkus
... [an] assertive, intensely researched, sometimes unconvincing, but always entertaining account.

Publishers Weekly
... scattershot.