The I Index

Tim Blanning,
The Wall Street Journal
...invigorating.
Andre Moravcsik,
Foreign Affairs
This magisterial study addresses the central question in modern German history: How and why did the country embrace a racial and cultural nationalism that ultimately led to war and genocide?.
Ian Buruma,
Harper's
In his absorbing and enlightening new book...the historian Helmut Walser Smith makes a convincing case that nations undergo so many complex changes that it is nonsense to assume that any particular period—including Hitler’s Third Reich—is wholly determined by the past, let alone a very distant past.
Frederic Krome,
Library Journal
Smith rejects the notion that German history is the story of militant nationalism marching toward genocide, and instead focuses on cartographers intellectuals who, prior to 1918, often described the landscape and ethnography of Germany in pacifistic terms. This new perspective on German history should be welcomed by all libraries..

Kirkus
Even though Germans are now resolute internationalists, Smith concludes, there are troubling rumblings of a reborn nationalism in opposition to the German government’s comparatively open-door policy toward immigrants and refugees, so that 'public discourse now seems increasingly rife with prejudice toward outsiders'.

Publishers Weekly
Vanderbilt University history professor Smith...traces shifting concepts of the German nation across five centuries in this dense and erudite account.