The I Index

Ed Simon,
The Chicago Review of Books
... fascinating, brilliant, comprehensive, and beautiful.
Art Edwards,
The Los Angeles Review of Books
Instead of a cri de cœur, O’Gieblyn gathers, analyzes, and disseminates a broad swath of theological, intellectual, and technological history to offer some sense of the intellectual condition in which we find ourselves today...The strength of O’Gieblyn’s book rests on her ability to distill the arguments of a number of great thinkers on questions surrounding this technology, and she traces her ability to plumb these depths and emerge with something coherent to her time as a Christian in Bible school, when she learned to debate for hours ideas such as predestination and covenant theology.
Becca Rothfeld,
The New York Times Book Review
... nimble.
Bryce Christensen,
Booklist
Though O’Gieblyn laces her reflections with scholarship illuminating historical and cultural context, her narrative is ultimately sustained by her very personal account of a painful philosophical evolution. A compelling reminder that the deepest philosophical queries guide and shape life..

Kirkus
Much of this intellectually wide-ranging, occasionally knotty book turns on the ways we reflexively apply religious imagery to online life... The author is a whip-smart stylist who’s up to the task of writing about this material journalistically and personally.

Publishers Weekly
... intelligent.