Skip to main content

The I Index

Jennifer Szalai,
The New York Times
... smart and provocative.
Roger Bishop,
BookPage
... enlightening and provocative.
Daniel Bessner,
The New Republic
... a continuation of Moyn’s decade-long critique of human rights and the liberal ideology that undergirds them. But, unlike his earlier books, Humane expresses a more avowed anti-imperialism, looking specifically at the misplaced idealism used to justify American Empire to the nation’s elites.
Dexter Filkins,
The New Yorker
Moyn’s argument goes beyond the expected humanitarian critique—the Tolstoyan concern that mannerly military action could promote further suffering.
Dennis C. Jett,
The Washington Post
One development that was essential to this evolution of modern, interminable conflict was the creation of a legal framework that made the 'war on terror' defensible.
Rayan Fakhoury,
Los Angeles Review of Books
... compelling and authoritative.
Frederick J. Augustyn Jr.,
Library Journal
Readers will learn much about the views of post–World War II legal influencers, such as Telford Taylor, Richard Falk, and John Yoo, and may be surprised by the continuity of evolving policies and arguments on hostilities during the administrations of George H. W. Bush through Donald Trump.
Robert D. Kaplan,
The New York Times Book Review
[Moyn] he takes the reader on an excruciating journey, in incisive, meticulous and elegant prose, about the modern history of making war more legal, and in effect sanitizing it so that it can continue forever.

Kirkus
The author locates some of origins of the comparatively sanitized wars of the present in abolitionist and pacifist movements of the 19th century, although more interesting are the seeming contradictions he identifies in writers such as Carl von Clausewitz.

Publishers Weekly
... provocative.