Skip to main content

The I Index

Kimberley Harrington,
The Washington Post
Bound to be passed furtively from friend to friend and gobbled up after the kids go to bed. It will make for an electrifying book club pick.
Jennifer Wilson,
The New Yorker
Roden Winter is writing in unstinting detail about the mechanics of her marriage’s transition from monogamous to open (some sex on the side) to fully polyamorous (in which couples are allowed to have full-fledged concurrent relationships). She holds nothing back, even when she should.
Tyler Austin Harper,
The Atlantic
An unsparing account of a polyamorous life.
Katy Duperry,
Library Journal
Winter shares her and her husband’s deeply personal, candid story about deciding to make their relationship non-monogamous.

Kirkus
The author has a difficult time articulating why the idea of an open marriage appealed to her in the first place, and she doesn’t adequately explore other areas, especially related to her resentments against her husband. Winter also has a tendency to overwrite in places that don’t need it, so there can be too many adjectives, metaphors, or similes clogging the prose.