Skip to main content

The I Index

Laura Kipnis,
The New York Times Book Review
A slim collection of polemical reportage that I suspect is meant to be courageous stuff, also funny.
Becca Rothfeld,
The Washington Post
Attempts at scene-setting — a feeble homage to Didion’s magnificently visceral vignettes — fall flat.
Barton Swaim,
The Wall Street Journal
An astute, funny and splendidly written story of disillusionment.
Rachel Cooke,
The Observer (UK)
A wickedly enjoyable book.
Charles Kaiser,
The Guardian (UK)
For Bowles, longform turns out to be the chance to jettison the standards of accuracy of her previous employers in favor of the wildest possible generalizations.
Molly Fischer,
The New Yorker
It is difficult... to see Bowles’s subjects as more than caricatures when her descriptions of them are so generic.

Publishers Weekly
Thin.