Skip to main content

The I Index

Kathy Kiely,
The Washington Post
It’s hard to argue with Sullivan’s news judgment.
Steve Coll,
The New York Times Book Review
Sullivan has avoided the traps for the most part, combining highlights and lowlights of her glass-ceiling-defying career with an opinionated but fair and accessible tour of the big debates roiling the 'reality-based press'.
Jacob Bacharach,
The New Republic
A brisk—often too brisk—combination of professional memoir and essay in media criticism that juxtaposes Sullivan’s journalistic autobiography with expanded thoughts on some of the most central themes and topics of her media columns.
Charles Kaiser,
The Guardian (UK)
Beguiling.

Publishers Weekly
Sincere if befuddled.

Kirkus
The author, whose liberal perspective is occasionally heavy-handed, acknowledges that Trump helped change journalism: It need not be adversarial, she holds, but it will necessarily be that way if it tells the truth about liars, and objectivity is a less-desirable standard than truth in the face of endless mendacity.