The I Index

Rosa Brooks,
The Washington Post
... we knew all this already, didn’t we?.
Stephen Rohde,
Los Angeles Review of Books
... despite his 49 years reporting on Washington politics, 19 previous books, and two Pulitzer Prizes, Woodward comes off...as surprisingly naïve.
Jennifer Szalai,
The New York Times
Readers who pick up Bob Woodward’s new book, Rage, and are tantalized by the promise on its dust jacket of 'an utterly vivid window into Trump’s mind,' will quickly get schooled in a lesson that apartment hunters in New York often have to learn: A window can be only so vivid if it looks out onto an air shaft.
Isaac Chotiner,
The New Yorker
... typical of Woodward’s White House-centric narratives: inconsistencies pile up; narrative threads are dropped and then recovered without any notice of the ways in which they have altered in the interim.
Alexander Nazaryan,
Los Angeles Times
Woodward’s writing has the mouthfeel of gravel. In Rage, he serves up heaps of that inimitable Woodward prose.
Barton Swaim,
The Wall Street Journal
I mention all this simply to point out that the book’s one headline-making revelation is noteworthy only if you already believe that any terrible thing in the world is probably in some way the fault of Mr. Trump. But if that is your outlook, you don’t need a hefty book to tell you that Mr. Trump is a terrible guy. What is the point of Rage, then?.
Walter Clemens,
New York Journal of Books
Rage gives the reader the context for...major political events. But it also provides insights into the interactions between the president and those close to him.
William Varick,
Library Journal
Similar to Woodward’s previous book, Fear, only purchase for initial demand..
David Murphy,
The Open Letters Review
Trump’s attempt at introspection aside, this can, in fact, be a difficult book to rage at. On the one hand, at this late date, rage at Trump’s behavior is often akin to being thrown into a conniption over the conduct of a clown, and on the other, Rage itself is an unbearably stale read. Now, sure, nobody is buying Woodward’s books to enjoy literary playfulness or peppery prose on a free Sunday afternoon. And because of his earned reputation (have you deposed a president?), his access (seventeen interviews!), and meticulous (usually recorded and on the record) approach, he cannot be dismissed, and we can be certain that just about everything in the book is true - so it is practically self-recommending. But how on earth do you hand such a book to an educated member of the electorate when they must flog themselves to even reach the chapters on the COVID pandemic?.

Publishers Weekly
... another alarming and deeply reported account of turmoil, dysfunction, and recklessness within the Trump administration.