The I Index

Irina Reyn,
The New York Times Book Review
... a poignant, deeply researched account of the Pittsburgh Jewish neighborhood in the aftermath of tragedy.
Diane Cole,
The Washington Post
His compelling exploration of its impact on the community is by turns searing and compassionate. It is an emotionally draining terrain, flecked with occasional, unexpected pockets of consolation. But in placing this hate crime against our country’s patchwork canvas of faith, politics and violence, Oppenheimer provides a powerful meditation on the changing meaning of community and belonging in an age of disconnection and isolation.
Toby Tabachnick,
Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle
If you are wondering if an outsider could hope to capture the mood—maybe even the soul—of a neighborhood to which he does not belong following an unthinkably horrific event, I tender this take: Perhaps an outsider, as it turns out, is best suited to do so. Oppenheimer’s being far enough removed from Squirrel Hill allows him to observe meaningful details that could be too close in the line of vision for natives to see as clearly. Oppenheimer reports with candor and clarity in 18 chapters.
Julia M. Klein,
Forward
His immersive account—which also sheds light on the attack’s antecedents, historical context, and especially its geographic setting—is granular in its detail, emotionally intimate and often moving.
Jessica Bushore,
Library Journal
A devastating story of loss that becomes a story of societal resilience; essential reading for anyone seeking insight on gun violence..

Publishers Weekly
... a vivid and deeply empathetic look at Pittsburgh’s Squirrel Hill neighborhood in the aftermath of the October 2018 mass killing of 11 worshippers at a local synagogue.

Kirkus
In this wonderfully rendered narrative, Oppenheimer deftly shows how, when emotions are raw, the best intentions can misfire or fail to satisfy everyone.