The I Index

Heller McAlpin,
The Wall Street Journal
Among the handful of iconic hotels closely entwined with New York’s cultural history, the Barbizon is perhaps less widely known than the Plaza, Algonquin or Waldorf Astoria. But as Paulina Bren’s beguiling new book makes clear, its place in the city’s storied past is no less deserving.
Casey Cep,
The New Yorker
The historian Paulina Bren, in her new book, The Barbizon: The Hotel That Set Women Free (Simon & Schuster), chronicles the experiences of these women, and of some of the hundreds of thousands of others like them, who stayed in the hotel. More than a biography of a building, the book is an absorbing history of labor and women’s rights in one of the country’s largest cities, and also of the places that those women left behind to chase their dreams. In Bren’s telling, some of the same forces that brought them to Manhattan led to the end of the Barbizon as they knew it—and to the New York City that we know today.
Moira Donegan,
The New York Times Book Review
...captivating.
Barbara Bamberger Scott,
Bookreporter
Bren has brought the Barbizon into focus, helping us to better understand the place itself and the people who managed it and lived within its walls, some for many years .. That and many other gems have been gleaned by Bren in constructing this cultural memoir, centered on an unusually private shelter in a very public city. The Barbizon should be required reading for thoughtful, free-thinking women of all ages..
Mary Jo Murphy,
The Washington Post
... [a] lively history.
Daisy Goodwin,
The Sunday Times (UK)
... [an[ entertaining history.
Mary Norris,
The Times Literary Supplement (UK)
... a deeply researched history, leavened with gossip.
Barbara Spindel,
The Christian Science Monitor
Bren elegantly weaves interviews with former residents and archival research with context on the social and political conditions that limited midcentury women. She devotes attention both to those glamorous residents who made it big, including Joan Crawford and Grace Kelly, and those who tried and failed to live autonomously..
Kitty Kelley,
The Washington Independent Review of Books
Bren brings impressive academic credentials to her history of the Barbizon. Unfortunately, her book’s subject, at least in her telling, does not live up to its billing as 'the hotel that set women free.'.
Eliza Thompson,
Bust
Paulina Bren takes readers deep into the world of New York’s most famous women-only residential hotel.
Lisa Fernandes,
All About Romance
[A] handsome, fascinatingly-written volume about life in the women-only hotel.

Library Journal
Bren...excels with this insightful, well-written account.
Donna Seaman,
Booklist
... [a] scintillating, many-faceted history.

Publishers Weekly
Historian Bren...delivers an entertaining and enlightening account of New York’s Barbizon Hotel and the role it played in fostering women’s ambitions in 20th-century America.

Kirkus
Drawing on extensive research, extant letters, and numerous interviews, Bren beautifully weaves together the political climate of the times and the illuminating personal stories of the Barbizon residents. Although some parts of the narrative are repetitive, particularly regarding Plath and Kelly, the book remains captivating.