The I Index

Lucinda Robb,
Washington Post
[Kean's] delightful, highly readable indictment of scientists behaving badly is a timely reminder that no field is immune from corruption.
John Schwartz,
The New York Times
The Icepick Surgeon is a hodgepodge of stories about malfeasance and evil, loosely grouped under a high concept.
Aron Row,
San Francisco Book Review
Tales of scientific criminal activities told by the outstanding science storyteller Sam Kean.
Brandy Schillace,
The Wall Street Journal
... this book is more than a gathering of amusing vignettes. As each chapter compounds, it becomes more difficult to condemn and smirk without seeing the systemic ways that early sins have crept into the heart of science and medicine today.
Elizabeth Svaboda,
Salon
Expert at spinning historical science yarns, Kean presents a scientific rogues' gallery that's both entertaining and chilling.
Joseph Barbato,
New York Journal of Books
The Icepick Surgeon is filled with fascinating, sometimes horrifying stories of scientists trying to solve human problems, often ignoring human concerns .. Sam Kean’s crisp, bright storytelling makes these tales of out-of-control scientists irresistible..
Kate Bellody,
Library Journal
A witty, thought-provoking book.

Publishers Weekly
Kean delivers a fascinating survey of crimes committed by scientists.

Kirkus
Kean is on surer footing with his later, brightly told anecdotes of a host of scientists and para-scientists who merrily crossed the ethical line in the quest for glory and sometimes wealth.