Skip to main content

The I Index

Rachel Donadio,
The New York Times Book Review
It’s a testament to Sands — his fiercely inquiring mind, his excellent researchers, the wealth of documents and his ability to make them come to life — that the book is so suspenseful.
Claire Messud,
Harpers
... damning and meticulously researched.
Ashish Ghadiali,
The Guardian (UK)
This is a taut and finely crafted factual thriller, reminiscent in density and pace of John le Carré.
Dominic Sandbrook,
The Sunday Times (UK)
Sands’s untangling of the mysteries surrounding Otto von Wächter is masterfully done.
David Herman,
New Statesman (UK)
... a fascinating follow-up to East West Street.
Fiona Sturges,
iNews (INDO)
Out of Sands’ exhaustive research comes an intimate love story—despite Otto’s infidelities, he and Charlotte remained devoted to one another, and she defended his wartime actions long after his death—and a tale of deception, as Otto strived to cover up his crimes and hide from those who would bring him to justice.
Mark Ellis,
The Los Angeles Review of Books
With the skills of a gifted historian and a highly regarded international criminal lawyer, Sands tells the story of Horst Wächter struggling to come to terms with his father’s past as a Nazi war criminal.
CAROLYN KELLOGG,
The Los Angeles Times
Sands lays out a riveting, deeply researched case that builds chronologically to show who and what Otto was.
Ian Thomson,
Evening Standard (UK)
In fast-paced, John le Carré-like pages (spies, Nazi-hunters, dark Vatican forces), Sands charts his own changing relationship with the deluded Horst von Wächter.
Rebecca Abrams,
Financial Times (UK)
The forensic stamina and precision that garnered such praise for Sands’ 2016 work East West Street are equally in evidence here.
Thomas Tracey,
The Irish Times (IRE)
... the outcome of Sands’s meticulous and startling research, revealing a truly labyrinthine investigation.
David Miller,
Library Journal
... a real-life thriller that is stranger than fiction.
Gary Day,
Booklist
There’s no question that Sands is a superlative historical researcher and excellent writer, but, ultimately, Wächter’s career as a Nazi was unremarkable, and his postwar life and death of interest mostly to detail-obsessive academic historians specializing in Nazism..

Publishers Weekly
... [a] solemn, graceful, and powerful account.

Kirkus
... [a] fascinating, disturbing story.