The I Index

Dan Kois,
Slate
Smith attempts to tell the entire 21st-century story of online media, and quite a bit of that story ends up in the book. Smith’s particularly good when he close-reads a particular publication in its ephemeral context.
Virginia Heffernan,
The New York Times Book Review
Engrossing and suspenseful.
Max Read,
The Washington Post
There is lots of delusion in this book. There is also a little bit of rivalry. But I have to be honest. I do not think there are any geniuses.
Aaron Timms,
The New Republic
Through the stories of BuzzFeed and Gawker, Smith aims to show how the media, high on the early internet’s spirit of creative adventure and freedom, got hooked on traffic.
Lloyd Green,
The Guardian (UK)
Graced with a keen eye and sharp wit, [Smith] has seen and heard plenty.
Nathan Heller,
The New Yorker
Illuminating.
Leah Finnegan,
The Baffler
Smith is a smart guy, a good reporter, and exudes an endearing—and enduring—earnestness about the media.
Teresa Xie,
NPR
Ben Smith, former editor-in-chief of Buzzfeed News, lands on his promise to chronicle the rise of digital media through the story of a snowballing, head-to-head competition — between characters like Peretti and Nick Denton of Gawker Media, between the right and the left and, eventually, between the new found power of social networks and the institutions they helped create..

Kirkus
he author gives a detailed, smart account of the foibles of those early days, when no one knew how to conduct decent journalism and make money at the same time.

Publishers Weekly
Riveting.