Skip to main content

The I Index

Phosphorescence: A Memoir of Finding Joy When Your World Goes Dark

Bottom of the pile

13

/100

I Index Overall Rating

Readers

22/100

Critics

4/100

Scholars

N/A

Author:

Julia Baird

Publisher:

Random House

Date:

July 6, 2021

After surviving a difficult heartbreak and battle with cancer, Australian journalist Julia Baird began launched an exploration of how she and others persevere through the most challenging circumstances life throws at us. And she returned with a guide for others who are going through their own dark periods.

What The Reviewers Say

Carol Haggas,
Booklist
The...compilation of contemplative essays is hard to categorize, a heady and poignant combination of self-help, memoir, and scholarly enlightenment. A popular Australian broadcaster, journalist, and author, Baird brings a shimmering intimacy to a universal condition, a beacon of light that both blazes with intensity and bathes with comforting reassurance..
Stacy Shaw,
Library Journal
Her writing on her experiences with cancer is truly heartbreaking. She touches on these experiences only briefly, although the beginning of the book indicates that it deals with her life's dark periods as an overarching motif. As a result, it can be difficult to see where the writing leads to; Baird discusses instead the activism of her youth, letters to her son and daughter, and her time living in places around the world. This, paired with her beginning section on awe, wonder, and silence, which seemed more scientifically centered, does not synthesize into a unified book.

Kirkus
... emotional, introspective.

Publishers Weekly
Unfortunately, she flounders when wandering into bland self-improvement advice, with an overabundance of secondary sources, inspirational quotes, a platitude-laden 'my darling daughter' missive...and cringe-inducing rhapsodies about finding one’s own 'tribe' (alongside, it should be noted, valuable lessons from Aboriginal cultures). There are sparks and flares of brilliance to be found, but overall the assembly never burns brighter than standard inspirational genre fare..