Skip to main content

The I Index

Otherlands: A Journey Through Earth’s Extinct Worlds

Top of the pile

79

/100

I Index Overall Rating

Readers

64/100

Critics

93/100

Scholars

N/A

Author:

Thomas Halliday

Publisher:

Random House

Date:

February 1, 2022

Mining the most recent paleontological advances, a paleobiologist recreates 16 extinct worlds, rendered with a novelist's eye for detail and drama, showing up close the intricate relationships of these ancient worlds.

What The Reviewers Say

James McConnachie,
Sunday Times (UK)
Wonderful.
Amancai Biraben,
Associated Press
Densely detailed.
David P. Barash,
The Wall Street Journal
Much of Otherlands is written in the present tense, which feels a bit creepy until the reader gets into the rhythm, at which point the narrative becomes shockingly real and immediate, as individual dramas and entire, vibrant panoramas unfold in what feels like real time.
Jon Turney,
Arts Desk (UK)
A brilliant series of reconstructions of life in the deep past, richly imagined from the fine details of the fossil record ...There are passing hints of how particular fossils were formed, and why specific locations yielded a rich haul, but the details are passed by – if you wan that kind of thing you will have to follow up the extensive notes. The exposition is also mercifully light on the cliches of Attenborough-style narration, where every scene seems to be either a mating opportunity or a meal.