Skip to main content

The I Index

A World Without Police: How Strong Communities Make Cops Obsolete

Next in the queue

50

/100

I Index Overall Rating

Readers

45/100

Critics

10/100

Scholars

95/100

Author:

Geo Maher

Publisher:

Verso

Date:

August 24, 2021

Surveying the post-protest landscape in Minneapolis, Philadelphia, Chicago and Oakland, as well as the people who have experimented with policing alternatives at a mass scale in Latin America, Maher details the institutions we can count on to deliver security without the interventions of cops: neighborhood response networks, community-based restorative justice practices, democratically organized self-defense projects and well-resourced social services.

What The Reviewers Say

Kamil Ahsan,
NPR
This all may seem ripped from an overly broad, unrigorous, and dogmatic polemic, but Maher's book is nothing if not exhaustive.
Charles Fain Lehman,
City Journal
The book is a strangled cry for attention—a demand that we return to the fantasy world a few activists inhabited ever so briefly last summer, before rioting and violence snapped us back to reality. Why get rid of the police? Much of Maher’s answer is standard-issue babble.

Kirkus
Is the cry to defund the police mere rhetoric? No way, this book makes clear.

Publishers Weekly
... [a] provocative and well-researched polemic.