Skip to main content

The I Index

Bottom of the pile

23

/100

I Index Overall Rating

Readers

28/100

Critics

17/100

Scholars

N/A

Author:

Nathan Ward

Publisher:

Atlantic Monthly Press

Date:

September 5, 2023

A narrative of the Old West told through the outsized life of cowboy, detective, and chronicler Charlie Siringo.

What The Reviewers Say

Dan Piepenbring,
Harpers
As with much of Ward’s source material, Siringo’s life can feel retrospectively absurd, too authentic to be real.
Andrew R. Graybill,
The Wall Street Journal
As much a chronicle of the Old West as it is the study of a colorful, and ubiquitous, frontiersman.
Anna Heyward,
The New York Times Book Review
Ward’s book is dense with research and description. Sometimes too dense. Colorful stories — of horse thieving, dangerous wagon journeys, double-crossing and shootouts — occasionally sag under the weight of benign particulars..
Kathleen Townsend,
Booklist
The larger-than-life, Texas-born cowboy Charlie Siringo lived a life normally reserved for fiction, one every bit as full of adventure, intrigue, and derring-do as any western movie.