Skip to main content

The I Index

Unworthy Republic: The Dispossession of Native Americans and the Road to Indian Territory

Next in the queue

70

/100

I Index Overall Rating

Readers

77/100

Critics

35/100

Scholars

97/100

Author:

Claudio Saunt

Publisher:

W. W. Norton & Company

Date:

March 24, 2020

A history of 'Indian Removal,' the forced migration of Native Americans across the Mississippi River in the 1830s and the state-sponsored theft of their lands.

What The Reviewers Say

Nick Romeo,
The Washington Post
Saunt’s book is a major achievement, commendable for his candor about the horrors of expulsion and his illumination of the crucial role that Southern slaveholdersβ€”eyeing Indian lands to take over for themselvesβ€”played in shaping early 19th-century American Indian policy. This alone would make for an important study, but he also manages to do something truly rare: destroy the illusion that history’s course is inevitable and recover the reality of the multiple possibilities that confronted contemporaries.
Jennifer Szalai,
The New York Times
... a powerful and lucid account, weaving together events with the people who experienced them up close.
Caitlin Fitz,
The Atlantic
... a damning synthesis of the federal betrayals, mass deportations, and exterminatory violence that defined the 1830s.
Peter Cozzens,
The Wall Street Journal
...Mr. Saunt presents a passionate and provocative account of what he calls β€œone of the first state-sponsored mass expulsions in the modern world”; the 'U.S. counterpart of Europe’s β€˜Jewish question.' ” He convincingly argues that the root cause of the expulsion of the Indian inhabitants of the South was a vile mix of racial antipathy, unbounded greed and the naive idealism of self-styled Indian experts.