Skip to main content

The I Index

War on the Border: Villa, Pershing, the Texas Rangers, and an American Invasion

Maybe someday

43

/100

I Index Overall Rating

Readers

49/100

Critics

37/100

Scholars

N/A

Author:

Jeff Guinn

Publisher:

Simon & Schuster

Date:

May 18, 2021

The story of how U.S.-Mexico border tensions erupted into open warfare in 1916, as a U.S. military expedition crossed the border to try to capture Mexican guerrilla Pancho Villa--a military incursion whose effects still haunt the border region to this day.

What The Reviewers Say

Peter Cozzens,
The Wall Street Journal
The book doesn’t fully deliver on its ostensible purpose, however. Although engagingly written, it is a largely unoriginal, thinly researched work that, judging by the author’s notes, relies heavily on secondary sources and on interviews with modern historians. The result is a story that concentrates as much on the endless intriguing among the parade of Mexican strongmen and idealists who wrestled for control of Revolutionary Mexico, and on nearly a century of American-Mexican relations prior to 1916, as it does on the professed topic of the book.
Jeff Guinn,
Bookreporter
... [a] skillfully written history.
WIlliam Rice,
Washington Independent Review of Books
... [a] galloping new narrative.
Maria Bagshaw,
Library Journal
... an excellent history of a defining moment in U.S.–Mexico relations, especially as the author explains the complexities of the Mexican Revolution (1910–24) in engaging detail.